Among reviewer’s problems is actually the publication described “my” an such like since the determiners, after they was indeed indeed (in his viewpoint) pronouns
– I really do agree with you throughout the keeping terms to a minimum within the coaching, and that i offer your one pupils tend to be attending see what adjectives is than just determiners.
Actually, I think I recently reference “my”etc given that possessives should your you want arises, and this is not that have a tendency to (they will not frequently trigger many harm to Polish learners, no less than). However, direction guides occasionally reference determiners, and so i have to be able to determine them.
The point I found myself while making so you’re able to Syed Usman is actually it is unsafe to speak in absolutes within the code. Simply because their language area and you can mine refer to “my” an such like since determiners and you can “mine” etcetera because the “possessive pronouns” it doesn’t mean that a person else writing on “my” an such like once the possessive pronouns are necessarily wrong. Which is undoubtedly exactly how many linguists reference them, such as for instance.
We analyzed which the difficult ways. I got simply written an article getting my personal site towards determiners and you may pronouns, when i spotted a tremendously (unfairly if you ask me) worst overview of a keen EFL grammar book towards a japan cupid blogs having a distinctly linguistics angle. Whenever i dared so you can feedback this particular is actually certainly simple during the EFL, the guy cited Huddleston and you can Pullum in the myself, and i also got a beneficial lecture in the “determinatives” (that i had never ever heard of – neither I do believe, have numerous some one).
Once i are alternatively worried I would first got it all completely wrong within the my article, I did a little research on the whole determiner / determinative topic (it’s a touch of a mess), and therefore my regard to both of these site guides. But have you to definitely strong concept back at my weblog, that’s which i use the popular conditions out of EFL, so I am adhering to the standard EFL and you will dictionary concept of determiner I’d currently put, and you may leaving brand new strange and you will wonderful content to the linguists..
We consent. In the event the some one questioned just what an excellent determiner was, I’d simply let them have a list. BTW into the Hungarian, palms is accomplished with noun endings not separate words.
No matter how I consider it, ‘Mine and Greg’s’ seems to be proper
Very first, you’ve got the target, the ‘child.’ And then you feel the a couple of possessors, ‘Greg,’ additionally the pronoun for ‘yourself.’ According to hence person you’re creating into the, the trouble associated with process may differ. Very first body’s awful that have material possessives!
Bring it which have a whole grain regarding salt; my personal ultra-super-cool qualifications lie when you look at the of many treacherous and you may unedited territories away from Fanfiction; I would not be amazed basically was deciding on so it completely backwards!
Together with, when in question, was claiming the latest phrase out loud. ‘My and you may Greg’s child’ compared to ‘Mine and you may Greg’s child’–what type sounds top? You realize which I would personally match. Only sayin’.
– and there lays an element of the condition: it is uncertain separate from whether we play with ‘my’ otherwise ‘mine’. (We observe that in my own very first comment I had presumed they was in fact speaking of just one man,however, into the 2nd look I might well thought a couple was basically getting labeled.
What’s more it seems in my experience unnatural for reasons I mentioned earlier. The individual got currently removed the kid/people to school, so allegedly realized their name(s) – consider use only their labels as opposed to that it quite uncomfortable structure?
In addition I can not agree with Ashley:) – in so far as i learn, we virtually avoid using possessive pronouns till the individual otherwise question has been said (but perhaps in book headings). “Greg’s man and you can exploit” may indeed performs, in the event the truth be told there a couple youngsters, or even more, however, “Mine and you can Greg’s boy”? I do believe perhaps not.